Esurance vs Progressive Car Insurance

Discovering the perfect insurance coverage involves navigating a maze of factors—from credit scores to driving records. In this comprehensive analysis, we’ve dissected crucial data points, delving into how Esurance and Progressive tailor their rates across various customer profiles. Dive into our breakdown of credit scores, mileage, coverage levels, and driving history to uncover which company offers the most favorable rates for your specific needs and circumstances.

*monthly rates are based on an average of minimum and full coverage for a 45-year-old male driver

Esurance Car Insurance

Pros:

• Online Convenience: Esurance has been offering purely online insurance coverage since 1999, making it a convenient option for tech-savvy customers who prefer to handle their insurance needs digitally.
• LGBT Support: Esurance is known for offering discounts to same-sex couples and supporting the LGBT community through corporate sponsorships.
• Competitive Discounts: The company offers competitive discounts to its customers, which can result in potential cost savings.
• Partnerships: Esurance has partnered with various sports teams and initiatives, such as “Save a Windshield, Plant a Tree.”

Cons:

• Smaller Market Share: Esurance has a smaller market share compared to Progressive, which might result in fewer available features and discounts.
• Customer Satisfaction: Customer satisfaction ratings may vary as Esurance’s customer service might change following its acquisition by Allstate.
• Possibly Higher Premiums: Reports suggest that Esurance may have slightly higher premiums than Progressive in some cases.

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Progressive Car Insurance

Pros:

• Market Leader: Progressive is a well-established insurance provider and known for its cutting-edge technology and innovative features.
• High Customer Satisfaction: Progressive has one of the highest customer satisfaction scores in the industry, ranking just behind Geico and USAA according to JD Powers’ annual auto insurance survey.
• Sponsorships and Initiatives: Progressive sponsors various sports programs and is involved in initiatives like the Automotive X PRIZE.
• Comprehensive Discounts: Progressive offers a range of discounts and features, including pay-as-you-drive insurance and pet injury coverage.

Cons:

• Possibly Higher Premiums: While Progressive is known for offering competitive rates, it’s important to note that actual premiums may vary depending on individual factors.
• Limited Online-Only Advantage: Progressive has also adopted online services, potentially reducing the advantage of Esurance’s online-only approach.
• Size May Impact Personalized Service: As a larger company, the personalized service experience may not be as prominent compared to smaller insurers.

Best Car Insurance Company: Progressive

When comparing Esurance and Progressive car insurance, it’s clear that Progressive stands out as the better option overall. This determination is based on various factors, including rates, features, and customer satisfaction.

Competitive Rates: While both companies offer discounts and competitive rates, Progressive often comes out on top when it comes to affordability. This is mainly due to its size and ability to offer more discounts to its policyholders.

Innovative Features: Progressive is known for its innovative approach to insurance, introducing features like pay-as-you-drive insurance and pet injury coverage. These offerings can provide valuable added protection for policyholders.

High Customer Satisfaction: Progressive has consistently received high customer satisfaction ratings, ranking closely behind industry leaders like Geico and USAA. This indicates that customers are generally satisfied with their service and claims experience.

Established Market Presence: Progressive has been in the insurance business since 1937, making it an established and trusted choice for many customers. Its longevity in the industry speaks to its reliability.

While Esurance has its advantages, including online convenience and its commitment to supporting the LGBT community, Progressive’s combination of competitive rates, innovative features, and high customer satisfaction positions it as the best car insurance company overall. When all factors are considered, Progressive emerges as the preferred choice for those seeking reliable and cost-effective auto insurance coverage.

Esurance and Progressive: Company Origins

Esurance has been around since 1999, when it was one of the first companies to offer purely online insurance coverage. Since then, the company has grown substantially, and as of 2011, it is owned by Allstate. One of the primary reasons Allstate acquired the company was to spread out into the online insurance niche, which has so far been dominated by Progressive and Geico. Although Esurance offers many very competitive discounts, it’s still relatively unknown to many consumers and holds a relatively small number of policies.

Progressive is one of the better-known providers of auto insurance. It was founded in 1937 but didn’t become well-known until it began offering policies directly to consumers over the Internet. Since its inception, Progressive has been particularly well-known for its cutting-edge technology and features. Many common insurance features in recent years, like pay-as-you-drive insurance and pet injury coverage, were initially pioneered by Progressive.

On the whole, Progressive has a higher customer satisfaction ranking than Esurance; in fact, Progressive has one of the highest customer satisfaction scores of any insurance company, ranking just behind Geico and USAA in several categories according to the JD Powers annual auto insurance survey. Since Esurance has only recently been acquired by Allstate, its customer service may change for better or worse in upcoming years.

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Features of Each Insurance Company

Progressive sponsors many sports programs, and the field for the Cleveland Indians has been renamed to Progressive Field in the company’s honor. It also provides sponsorship for the Automotive X PRIZE, which is an international competition for concept cars operating at 100 MPG. The person who designs the most fuel-efficient and sustainable vehicles can enter for a chance at the $10 million prize.

Esurance is the first company to begin offering discounts to same-sex couples. Since then, it’s expanded its support of the LGBT community through various corporate sponsorships, including the Trevor project. It’s also an active supporter of several sports teams, and has partnered with the program “Save a Windshield, Plant a Tree,” which plants a tree for every windshield that’s repaired rather than replaced.

Progressive insurance offers several discounts and features such as:

• Accident forgiveness after four years of safe driving
• A $50 one-time discount for e-signing your policy
• Multi-policy discounts for homeowners
• Multi-car discounts for people with more than one vehicle
• A discount to customers who pay their premiums in full
• A discount to people who enroll in the Snapshot program for usage-based insurance
• Young driver discount when added to an existing policy
• Pet injury protection coverage
• Loyalty rewards to reduce the rates of people with long-term policies

By comparison, Esurance offers discounts such as:

• Claim-free discount after five years of safe driving
• Multi-car discount
• Homeowner’s discount
• “Switch and save” discount for drivers changing from another company
• Save 5% by signing up online
• Get a discount for paying in full
• Alumni discount for students of PAC-12

Several other discount options are available to certain drivers through both insurance companies. Be sure to ask to see what else you may qualify for based on your age, driving history and the type of car you drive.

Cost Comparison

On the whole, Progressive ends up having cheaper policies than Esurance, according to some reports. This may be due to the size of the company, which allows Progressive to offer more discounts than its smaller competitors. However, published premiums are not always a good comparison since many factors influence your premiums and most published rates are based on a profile that may not be anywhere close to resembling yours. Before choosing any car insurance company, always make to sure to get several quotes from different companies. Both Esurance and Progressive have millions of happy customers who renew every year so focus on finding coverage right for your family versus spending sleepless nights trying to choose a provider based on the company’s name.

Online Service

Esurance is known for its online experience that allows drivers to purchase car insurance quickly and easily, but industry leader Progressive has competitive online tools, too. As a result, both offer smarter products, seamless digital and mobile experiences, and better, more intuitive, tools.

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

The Bottom Line

Progressive and Esurance are two reputable providers of auto insurance to only approach a single vendor for your insurance needs could mean you are leaving money on the table. Automobile coverage is not a single product: there are many levels and types of coverage, all at different price points.

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption